
Each week during the season, we look at the big events and big games around Division I men’s college hockey in Tuesday Morning Quarterback
Ed Trefzger: Eric, I’m delighted to have this opportunity to banter with you about college hockey this week.
Let’s start with a team from the conference you follow most closely, the Big Ten. In its last two weekends — punctuated by an early bye week — Ohio State knocked the No. 1 team in the USCHO.com men’s Division I hockey poll off its perch.
On Halloween night, the Buckeyes upended visiting Michigan. 5-2, including a couple of empty-net goals, and took the Wolverines to overtime, only to drop that game 5-4. Still, those were four big points in the Big Ten standings. That allowed then-unbeaten Wisconsin to slide into the top spot in the poll.
This past Saturday, Ohio State downed host Wisconsin in front of more than 12,000 at the Kohl Center, 2-1, for a weekend split.
On the other side of the ledger, Ohio State has split with RPI and Sacred Heart, and got swept by still-unbeaten Augustana. Despite a 4-6-0 record, Steve Rohlik’s Buckeyes are at No. 14 in the NPI as we write this, no doubt buoyed by the wins against its two conference foes.
Without throwing around the overused word “parity,” what does this tell us about OSU, the Big Ten, and perhaps college hockey in general?
Eric Vegoe: Longtime listener of your podcast with Jim Connelly and Derek Schooley and first time partner in a Tuesday Morning Quarterback with you — I’m delighted to converse as well.
Parity is the overused word when it comes to results like the ones Steve Rohlik’s program has been able to pull off beating top ranked teams like Michigan and Wisconsin. The reality is that coaching and emotions in college hockey play a large role in these highly competitive hockey games and playing with a lead is a significant factor in these types of games.
Friday night saw the Badgers get on the board with a breakaway goal by Brent Solomon 1:44 into the game, extend the lead 10 minutes later and control the game until the end. Saturday was a little different as the Buckeyes got a goal late in the first period from Thomas Weis, Felix Caron extended the lead in the second and then Ohio State held on by limiting Wisconsin’s dangerous chances. The expected goals for Ohio State were just 1.9 on Friday and 1.7 on Saturday, but getting the lead allowed them to weather the storm and pull off the upset.
The Saturday result is also typical of western college hockey where it’s very difficult to sweep a two-game series. It’s rare for college players to play steady hockey two nights in a row with the highs of winning and lows of losing fresh in their emotions. Also the coaching is so good in college hockey that teams can make quick adjustments between games.
Ed: That excellent coaching is really helped by all of the video and analytics available now. I’ve had coaches tell me stories about duplicating VHS tapes on Mondays to mail out to other teams back in the day, and I remember watching “the video guy” with a camcorder. Video coordinators can now prepare clips for coaches to break down between periods, and in-game advanced stats can provide data for those in-game adjustments. Plus, the next morning, players can see clips of all their shifts.
What coaches probably can’t account for is a short bench due to injuries. When the House v. NCAA settlement was announced with a 26-player limit, many immediately thought there would be little leeway for injuries. If you used the 15 forwards, eight defensemen, and three goalie allocation, you’d still be a little tight. If two goalies got hurt, you’d have to dress someone as a backup. But it seems like we’re seeing shortages among skaters.
Boston College had 10 forwards and six defensemen in the lineup on Friday as they deal with numbers depleted by injuries. BC isn’t the only team facing this issue. It’s such a problem that the Big Ten on behalf of the D-I men’s hockey oversight committee is asking for the number to be increased to 28. I think I’d be OK with 30.
Even if you can skate a full complement, injuries can still have a big impact, especially if a top player is out. I don’t have any numbers to prove it, but it feels like the number of players out of lineups is pretty high in the first couple months of the season. What have you seen?
Eric: Roster limits were clearly put in place by administrators unfamiliar with how college hockey functions. There are other sports where short bench rotations are common. Certain sports like women’s basketball allow male practice players that aren’t considered part of the roster. Individual sports can just deal with being short on participating players. I don’t think that the administrators understand what happens with a short bench in college hockey. Boston College playing with just ten forwards meant their top line forwards played big minutes and others had season highs for time on ice.
I haven’t seen too many short lineups yet in the Big Ten this season. Notre Dame played Penn State earlier this year with just five defensemen, but it’s early in the year still. Michigan had five or six players participate through flu-like symptoms this past weekend against Penn State so that the Wolverines could field a full lineup. As teams have few options, this creates a lot of unnecessary injury risk for student athletes as they certainly don’t want to let their teammates down if they can “gut it out.” Certainly it could create potential problems with players returning from head injuries or trying to hide symptoms from team medical staff. Every game is significant in college hockey, especially when the margins around NPI are slim.
College hockey needs a way to address this risk going forward. I think rostering 30 players might be an over correction for an entire season, but 28 is a good start and I’d like programs to have the ability to add players midseason if they are dealing with season ending injuries especially at goalie. I’ve seen Minnesota at times where they don’t have a goaltender during the week for practice and have to put up a board or net in goal to get by for the week. I even once saw their goalie coach Brennan Poderzay put on the pads for a day — which I don’t think he would want to do again.
Boston College and Notre Dame won’t be the only teams fielding shorthanded lineups this year as injuries and illness pile up. Also don’t forget that as more talent plays NCAA hockey, more rosters will deal with players leaving for the World Junior Championship and the Spengler Cup in Davos, Switzerland.
Ed: That stretch during WJC and Davos is indeed another opportunity for an upset. And it could get even worse if a proposal floated at the coaches’ convention last spring ever gains traction.
Our colleague Brad Schlossman at the Grand Forks (N.D.) Herald reported back in May that coaches used the formation of the more independent D-I men’s hockey oversight committee I mentioned before to propose increasing the 34-game regular season to 40. That would probably require more games between semesters and some weeknights, too. I’m not sure I like the idea of additional weeknight games or more games during school breaks.
That increase would really widen the gap in games played for the six Ivy League teams. They’ve picked up one more allowed game this season, bringing the total to 30. I don’t think I’m overstepping by saying those coaches would agree that they should be allowed the full NCAA schedule. (Former Harvard coach Ted Donato advocated for that in a 2019 USCHO podcast appearance, and I know former Cornell coach Mike Schafer also strongly supported it.)
I brought this up in a recent USCHO Weekend Review podcast after seeing our managing editor John Doyle post a video about the Ivies on social media. It’s time for the Ivies to play a full schedule and start at the same time as everyone else. Dartmouth is one of two undefeated teams left, but they’ve played six fewer games than 9-0-3 Augustana. Maybe USCHO could help this along by not allowing votes for teams that haven’t started playing yet after the preseason poll is published. (Tongue in cheek, but not firmly.)
Eric: The Ivies let their teams play full NCAA basketball seasons. They let their football team play in the FCS playoffs. It’s time to let their hockey programs play a full season. College hockey has 62 D-I programs right now and it’s baffling to me that these six Ivy League teams are being held back. Year after year of Academic Progress Rate (APR) documentation shows that student athletes who play college hockey can handle the long season and academics. Men’s hockey finished seventh among all men’s sports and 66 percent of Ivy League men’s hockey programs’ multi-year rate scored above the national average of 984. I’m on board with holding back voting for these Ivy Leagues schools until they start playing, if it were to make any difference.
Increasing the number of games played is something just limited to the Ivies, as Denver coach David Carle has been lobbying for more games across college hockey lately. Adding a few more games makes sense as more highly drafted players from the CHL join the ranks and programs seek to retain them for more than just a year or two before they sign. Minnesota Hockey has addressed early departures from their high school programs by increasing the number of games their athletes play each year with a couple creative solutions. Their Elite League adds 20 games to the year for top 14-18 year olds across the region before their high school season begins and their Spring High Performance program adds some festivals and camp to bookend the season in the spring. This effort has been put in place to provide more development opportunities for players who stay.
Players moving on to professional hockey is something college coaches deal with every April and providing a more complete season might entice student athletes to at least stay three seasons and be closer to departing with a degree.
Great back and forth today Ed! College hockey has never been in a better spot and you could say the same for youth hockey in Minnesota — I hope that the powers in charge of college hockey continue to grow the game and make decisions to assist that growth as resting on one’s laurels won’t grow the game.